Orbs: Dust, Spirits, or ??
Orbs: Dust, Spirits, or Something We Still Don't Understand?
Following on from our recent Facebook post, we thought it was time to take a closer look at one of the most debated subjects in paranormal investigation: orbs.

When I asked for your thoughts on orbs, I honestly was not expecting quite such a variety of answers! From dust, bugs, moisture and lens flare to aliens, interdimensionals, plasma and even advanced light energy that supposedly observes, monitors and tracks humans, the responses certainly gave us plenty to think about. Some answers made us smile, some made us curious, and others left us genuinely intrigued. But these responses raise an important question: “What exactly are we looking at when an orb appears in a photograph or video?” And perhaps an even more important question: “How do we determine whether something is paranormal or simply something we don't immediately understand?”
Paranormal Investigation is about more than belief. There is sometimes a misconception that paranormal investigators see something unusual and immediately call it a ghost or a spirit although, in reality, responsible paranormal investigation should involve much more than that. Scientific method should be an important part of a thorough paranormal investigation and that means observing, recording, testing possible explanations, gathering evidence and reviewing the results rather than allowing our beliefs or bias to determine what we think we have found. When something unusual appears during an investigation, we should first ask ourselves what could have caused it and if it could be explained by the environment, the equipment, lighting conditions or something else entirely?
We should document the circumstances, consider alternative explanations and, where possible, attempt to reproduce the effect under controlled conditions. If an ordinary explanation accounts for what we have observed, we must be prepared to accept that. But, if we cannot find an explanation, we can record it as unexplained and continue investigating. We cannot simply jump from "we don't know what it is" to "it must be paranormal."
That distinction is absolutely crucial. Being scientific doesn't mean dismissing the paranormal before an investigation even begins. It means being open to possibilities while demanding evidence before reaching a conclusion. After all, if we genuinely want to understand paranormal phenomena, surely we should want to know the difference between something that only looks mysterious and something that might actually challenge our current understanding.
Dust, Insects and Moisture: What Does the Evidence Tell Us?
Let's start with the explanations that are most frequently offered for photographic orbs.

Dust, tiny insects, pollen and moisture droplets are not simply convenient excuses invented to explain away unusual photographs. They are known physical objects, and the way they can produce orb-like images has been investigated, demonstrated and reproduced.
Here's how it works. When a photograph is taken in low light, a camera's flash or infrared illumination can light up tiny particles close to the lens. Because these particles are often too close for the camera to focus on properly, they appear as soft, circular, glowing shapes rather than clearly defined objects. This is an optical effect known as backscatter. Dust particles can reflect the flash, tiny insects can appear as bright circles or streaks, and moisture droplets can produce similar effects. Lens flare and internal reflections can also create unusual bright shapes in photographs. The results can look remarkably convincing, particularly when a photograph is taken in a dark building, or a location already associated with paranormal activity. But the important point is that these effects can be recreated experimentally.
Researchers and investigators have taken photographs under controlled conditions, introduced dust or moisture into the area near the camera, adjusted lighting and camera settings, and observed orb-like shapes appearing in the resulting images. Research into orb photography, including experiments published by the Association for the Scientific Study of Anomalous Phenomena (ASSAP), has examined how camera flash, focus, depth of field and other photographic factors contribute to these effects. In other words, there is a demonstrable physical mechanism that explains why many photographic orbs appear. We can test it, observe it and reproduce it.
Does this mean every single unusual light or circular shape has automatically been explained? No. Each image still needs to be examined on its own merits. However, it does mean we have solid reasons to investigate these ordinary explanations before considering something more extraordinary. We don't have to believe dust can create an orb. We can demonstrate that it can. And that is a very important difference.
So, Where Is the Scientific Proof That Orbs Are Spirits?

This is where the conversation becomes particularly interesting. Over the years, paranormal investigators have examined photographs, filmed unusual occurrences, used different types of equipment and attempted to find reliable evidence of spirit activity. Many investigators sincerely believe they have encountered something paranormal. Some have personal experiences they cannot explain, and I don't mean to dismiss the people who share them, but there is an important distinction between having an experience that feels paranormal and having evidence that scientifically establishes what caused it.
Despite years of interest and investigation, there is currently no reliable, independently verified scientific evidence establishing that the common glowing orbs seen in photographs are spirits. That is not the same as proving that spirits cannot exist. It means the specific claim that these photographic orbs are spirits has not been demonstrated. If an orb really is a spirit, what would we expect to observe? Could we measure something about it? Could we record its behaviour in a controlled environment? Could independent investigators repeat the observations and obtain comparable results? These are legitimate questions, and they deserve serious consideration.
Imagine if investigators could repeatedly document an orb under controlled conditions, rule out dust, insects, moisture, reflections and equipment artefacts, and obtain independent measurements demonstrating that something genuinely unexplained was occurring. That would be fascinating and give researchers something substantial to investigate further.
But until such evidence exists, we have to be honest about what we know and what we don't. We cannot claim that something is a spirit simply because we cannot identify the object in a photograph. Put simply, the absence of an explanation is not proof of a paranormal explanation. And if we want the paranormal field to be taken seriously, we must be willing to acknowledge that.
What About the Claim That 90% Are Dust and 10% Are Spirits?

One of the responses to our original question suggested that 90% of orbs are dust and 10% are spirit activity and I know that many people would agree with that. It's certainly an interesting suggestion, but it raises another question: how were those percentages established?
To make such a claim scientifically, we would need a reliable way to distinguish an ordinary orb from a genuine spirit orb. We would also need sufficient evidence to demonstrate that the identification was correct. At present, we don't have a scientifically validated method for identifying photographic orbs as spirits.
So, while the 90/10 theory might reflect personal beliefs or experience, we cannot treat those figures as established facts. And this is exactly why the scientific method matters. We need to separate personal opinions from observations, observations from interpretations, and interpretations from conclusions supported by evidence.
It might not be as exciting as declaring that we've photographed a spirit, but it is a much more reliable way of investigating the unknown.
Aliens, Interdimensionals and Advanced Energy?
Some of these responses took us well beyond dust and camera flare!
Aliens, interdimensional beings, plasma and advanced light energy that might observe or monitor humans were all suggested as possibilities. These are certainly thought-provoking ideas, but we need to be careful about how we approach them. There is currently no reliable evidence establishing that photographic orbs are extraterrestrial beings, interdimensional entities or intelligent energy forms tracking people.
Such suggestions are hypotheses, not established explanations. The same standard of evidence should apply to every theory, whether it comes from a sceptic or a believer. We shouldn't automatically accept a conventional explanation without examining the evidence, but neither should we accept an extraordinary explanation simply because it sounds intriguing.
The question isn't which theory is the most exciting. The question is: “Which explanation is best supported by the evidence?” That is what a proper investigation should aim to establish.
What If an Orb Appears Alongside Other Strange Activity?

Another response mentioned capturing orbs that appeared to be talking. That is certainly an intriguing claim, and it raises questions about what was observed and how it was recorded. Was the sound captured on the original recording? Was it audible at the time, or only noticed afterwards? Could background noise, interference or another source explain it? Similarly, what if an orb appears at the same time as an unexplained sound, an apparent change in temperature or another unusual event?
These circumstances may justify further investigation, but we need to establish whether the events are genuinely connected.
For example, if an orb appears in a photograph while an unexplained sound is recorded, that doesn't automatically mean the orb produced the sound or that both were caused by a spirit. We would need to examine each piece of evidence independently and then investigate whether there is a demonstrable relationship between them. This is where careful documentation becomes invaluable. Original recordings, accurate timestamps, environmental observations and repeated measurements are far more useful than relying on memory alone.
We should also be prepared for the possibility that an event remains unexplained, even after a thorough investigation. Sometimes the honest answer is simply that we don't know and there is absolutely nothing wrong with that.
Does Being Scientific Mean We Have to Be Sceptical About Everything?
I believe it means being willing to question everything, including our own assumptions. A good paranormal investigator shouldn't be afraid of finding an ordinary explanation. Nor should they be afraid to report something genuinely unusual when the available

evidence warrants further investigation.
If we approach every orb believing it must be a spirit, we risk overlooking the very things that could help us understand what we're seeing. But if we dismiss every unusual experience without investigating it, we may miss opportunities to learn something too.
The answer is to remain open-minded without abandoning critical thinking. We can respect people's experiences without automatically accepting their interpretations. We can acknowledge that there are questions we haven't answered without filling those gaps with assumptions. Most importantly, we should be prepared to change our minds when the evidence tells us we should.
That, in our view, is what responsible paranormal investigation should be about.
So, What Do We Think About Orbs?
My view is that a photographic orb should never be automatically labelled as a spirit.
There are well-established physical explanations for many of the glowing circles that appear in photographs, and these explanations can be tested and reproduced. Dust, insects, moisture and photographic artefacts must therefore be considered carefully before a paranormal interpretation is proposed. As for the claim that orbs are spirits, we have yet to see reliable scientific evidence that proves it. That doesn't prove spirits don't exist. It simply means that photographic orbs have not provided the proof we would need to establish that they do.
I understand why people find orbs fascinating. I understand why a strange photograph taken during an investigation can leave people wondering whether they have captured something extraordinary. But I also believe that genuine investigation requires more than a photograph and a theory about what it might represent. It requires questions, testing, evidence and a willingness to consider every reasonable possibility.
We don't want to believe something just because we want it to be true. We want to understand what we're observing and, wherever possible, establish why it happened. Because if we ever do encounter evidence that genuinely demonstrates something paranormal, we want that evidence to be strong enough to stand up to scrutiny.
Our job isn't to prove that every orb is paranormal. Our job is to investigate what we encounter and follow the evidence wherever it leads.
And perhaps that is the most important point of all.







Comments